I made noise during Evil Burn which I have never done in the theater before. It landed somewhere between laughter and apology, and I’ve done it more than once. That’s the whole review, really, but iHorror pays me per word, so let me explain what kind of movie deserves such sound.
What you’re actually signing up for
Alice, played by Souheila Yacoub, has just lost her husband and goes to mourn with her family in their isolated house. You already know that the family won’t stay a family for long. The Necronomicon does what it does, the people it’s supposed to rely on start turning into Deadites one by one, and a house full of sorrow becomes a house full of teeth. Sébastien Vaniček, the French director who made the skin crawl in Infestedruns the show here, and he treats the setup like a formality. He’s not wrong. The principle is a door, and it can’t wait to slam it behind you.
Vaniček knows where the wet things are
The best thing I can say about Vaniček is that he understands space and panic, and Infested proved both. This movie turned a dilapidated building into a smaller and smaller trap. He brings the same instinct to a single house, shooting hallways and stairwells as if they’re closing in, and cinematographer Philip Lozano keeps the camera low and close enough that you feel stuck in with everyone. When the film wants to move, it truly sprints. When he wants to sit in a doorway and let you dread the next room, he does that too, and the fear pays off.
Yacoub is the reason all of this is harder than a haunted house tour. She plays Alice with real heartbreak underneath, tired and raw before the blood even begins, and she engages in the physical wreckage without ever blinking at us. The supporting cast, including Hunter Doohan and Tandi Wright, do the hardest work in any possession movie, which is warm and human until they’re neither. And I have to mention makeup artist Jane O’Kane, whose hands-on work is the film’s true lead performance. The Deadites here are gnarled, weeping, wrong in a specific way that only someone who builds this thing by hand can manage. You can almost feel it.
To be shocked that the Book of the Dead bites
This is where I lose the people who left the theater upset. Some of the early responses to Evil Dead Burn landed on a version of too violent, too cruel, too much. Critics continue to circle this dividing lineand I understand the reflex. I also think it misinterprets what this show decided to be a long time ago.
Complaining that an Evil Dead movie is disgusting is like complaining that the Book of the Dead came without a warning label. This franchise stopped being just a cabin horror decades ago. Evil Dead II was already a slapstick soaked in arterial spray. Army of Darkness has become a full-on cartoon, an adventure more comedic than a nightmare, and no one would call it the most brutal chapter, but it follows in the tradition of treating the human body as a prop that exists to be dismembered for a laugh and a laugh. Fede Alvarez’s 2013 film swung the pendulum back to punishing practical cruelty, and Lee Cronin’s Evil Dead Rise moved the horror to a family apartment and made it intimate and nasty. Burn simply finds a new, dirtier corner of that same house and moves in.
And the violence is above all inventive, not just abundant, it’s the distinction that counts. O’Kane and Vaniček continue to find new ways to cut a person open, and the film understands exactly how often revulsion and laughter overlap. The meanest set pieces work because they heighten the idea rather than the volume. It’s not in good taste. Taste was taken to the parking lot before the opening credits finished. The film treats the human body less like a sacred container than like a package that has become truly difficult to open, and it rejoices in the effort made.
Where the seams appear
I loved this movie. I’m not going to pretend it’s airtight. The plot is thin, and I mean thin. There’s a heartbreak storyline that Yacoub sells harder than the script pays off, and a few supporting characters are barely sketched before the film needs them to start screaming. If you’re looking for a story that rewards a second viewing writing-wise, this isn’t it, and I’d be lying to you if I said otherwise.
The fact is that narrative weight was almost never an appeal here. No one opens the Necronomicon expecting a rich character study. You come for momentum, for demonic chaos, for the specific pleasure of seeing bodies cease to be permanent. Burn delivers all of this with the throttle turned down, so the threadbare plot stays mostly on the sidelines. Above all. The pace sags once into the middle third, just when the film should be tightening up, and there’s a late attempt at a larger digital creature breaking the convenient spell it spent an hour casting. For a movie so committed to things you can touch, the only moment it trusts a computer is the only moment I watched. This is a real flaw, and keeps it out of the high end of the series for me.
But the top tier of this series is stacked, and Burn doesn’t mind standing next to it. It’s not the best Evil Dead. It’s perhaps the most disgusting, and he wears it like a crown.
The verdict
Evil Dead Burn is story-thin, intentionally dirty, and creatively repellent in a way that made me happy to be there. Vaniček understood the mission, Yacoub anchored it, Jane O’Kane’s effects were worth all the setbacks, and only a late switch to digital kept him away from the top spot. If this extremity is a deal breaker for you, that’s fair, and I’m not here to dissuade you from getting out of your stomach. But if you walk into a movie called Evil Dead Burn and find yourself betrayed by the fact that it burns, I don’t know what to tell you. This is the series that does exactly what it promised, stronger.
Rating: 4 out of 5.
About the Author
